# Player Team Penalty goals
1 Jack Clarke Ipswich Town 6(6)
2 Zan Vipotnik Swansea 5(5)
3 Tommy Conway Middlesbrough 4(4)
4 Josh Windass Wrexham 3(3)
5 Carlton Morris Derby County 3(3)
6 McBurnie Hull City 3(3)
7 Jordan Ayew Leicester 2(2)
8 Cameron Brannagan Oxford United 2(2)
9 Haji Wright Coventry City 2(2)
10 Gustavo Hamer Sheff Utd 2(2)
11 Nicolas Madsen Queens Park Rangers 2(2)
12 Charlie Kelman Charlton Athletic 2(2)
13 Jaden Philogene Ipswich Town 2(2)
14 Jay Stansfield Birmingham City 2(2)
15 Sydie Peck Sheff Utd 2(2)
16 McLean Norwich 1(1)
17 Matt Grimes Coventry City 1(1)
18 Adam Armstrong Southampton 1(1)
19 Colby Bishop Portsmouth 1(1)
20 George Hirst Ipswich Town 1(1)
21 Brandon Thomas-Asante Coventry City 1(1)
22 Josh Maja West Brom 1(1)
23 Brewster Derby County 1(1)
24 Cantwell Blackburn Rovers 1(1)
25 Ben Brereton Díaz Derby County 1(1)
26 Victor Torp Coventry City 1(1)
27 Josh Sargent Norwich 1(1)
28 I. Louza Watford 1(1)
29 Edo Kayembe Watford 1(1)
30 Milutin Osmajic Preston North End 1(1)
31 Tomi Horvat Bristol City 1(1)
32 Idah Swansea 1(1)
33 Joe Gelhardt Hull City 1(1)
34 Yuki Ohashi Blackburn Rovers 1(1)
35 Jordan James Leicester 1(1)
36 Milan Smit Stoke 1(1)
37 Richard Kone Queens Park Rangers 1(1)