On October 14, Manchester United lost 0-2 away to Atlético Madrid in the Champions League group stage. The Athletic reported that Manchester United needed to win this crucial match against Atlético Madrid to ease pressure on manager Michael Carrick, but failed to do so. While Carrick bears some responsibility, Manchester United's poor form also reflects shortcomings by the players themselves.

According to reports, last week Manchester United drew 1-1 with Tottenham with 10 men and produced a lackluster performance. In that match, Carrick's team showed some improvement, but conceded within 53 seconds due to a defensive error, and struggled with a lack of finishing. In the second half, Leny Yoro received a red card, then Lookman scored the second goal, and Manchester United lost.

After the match, Lisandro Martínez publicly criticized the club's leadership, and this remarkable comment quickly drew attention, dominating public discourse for days.

This defeat means Carrick's team has not won since September 11, and faces a difficult away match against Leeds United on Sunday.

What Does This Defeat Mean for Michael Carrick?

After repeated disappointments and painful matches, Carrick needs to find positive aspects in the results, but how long can this situation continue?

Manchester United's problems against Atlético Madrid were not due to lack of intensity, an issue that has been criticized in many matches this season. In this match, the team moved the ball forward more quickly, found space between Atlético's defensive lines, and created several dangerous chances. The defensive line was unconventional and relatively inexperienced, but after the early goal, the team did not collapse as it had against Brighton. What truly ruined the match was the lack of precision and clinical finishing in decisive moments.

In the first half, Brian Mbeumo's close-range shot was saved. In the second half, Yuri Tielemans sent a long floating pass, and Bruno Fernandes followed up with a shot. Carlos Baleba also tried a header from a corner kick—all these chances could have broken the team's stalemate with a goal. However, what ultimately decided the match was that less than a minute after kickoff, Lee Kang-in's through pass broke through Manchester United's defense.

Carrick has repeatedly stated this season that mistakes at critical moments continue to hinder the team. Every team experiences this, but strong teams convert the chances they create into goals. Strong teams may occasionally lack concentration in defense, but they do not waste attacking opportunities at the same time. Top teams should avoid both problems. Against Atlético Madrid, Manchester United showed both issues.

How much of these problems stems from Carrick? The players must also bear responsibility. However, when positive play repeatedly fails to translate into goals and Manchester United keeps missing opportunities to change public perception, pressure on the manager will only increase.

Why Did Manchester United Collapse and Concede Within 53 Seconds?

In just 53 seconds, the dark cloud hanging over Manchester United deepened further. Atlético midfielder Barrios's shot deflected off a Manchester United player and rolled into goal. Given the defensive confusion in front of goal, this is hardly surprising.

Looking back at how this goal unfolded: at kickoff, Yuri Tielemans stood in the center circle. Tielemans played the ball back to goalkeeper André Onana, who immediately kicked a long ball out, giving possession to the home team.

This tactic was intended to press high immediately, a strategy commonly used by Arsenal and Paris Saint-Germain, who reached the Champions League final last season. From the replay, Manchester United's positioning appeared aggressive, and initially there was no great risk. Tielemans sprinted forward to press center-back Axel Witsel.

Witsel's pass was deflected by Baleba's sliding tackle, and the ball reached Lee Kang-in outside the center circle, which was somewhat fortunate. Lee Kang-in's only passing option in front of him was Álvaro Fernández. Curiously, Manchester United's right-back Dalot allowed Fernández to cut inside on his flank, and when Lee Kang-in sent the lob pass, Dalot was still running forward.

Fernández broke toward goal, and Manchester United's defenders rushed back, with Yoro and Dalot catching up to the attacker inside the penalty area. But in the confusion, no one marked Barrios, who was arriving late. Fernández sent a cross into the penalty area, and Barrios easily finished, deepening Michael Carrick's team's predicament.

Was Leny Yoro's Red Card Justified?

Leny Yoro received a red card in the 74th minute, an unfortunate incident that often occurs when a manager is already under immense pressure.

Atlético substitute Yusuf Tielemans sent a simple through ball, piercing Manchester United's defense and finding fellow substitute Jonathan David. Yoro's defensive action was clumsy but not a deliberate foul. While both contested for position, he merely made light contact with David's shoulder.

The foul occurred just beyond the halfway line in Manchester United's half, and the ball had already left the Canadian forward's possession. David immediately raised both arms, appealing to the referee to send off the opponent. After a lengthy VAR review, referee Glenn Nyberg showed a red card. Manchester United captain Bruno Fernandes protested the decision, but his protest had merit, as this was not an obvious goal-scoring opportunity.

Former Premier League referee Graham Scott commented: "Yoro extended his arm and placed his hand on David's shoulder, and there were no other defenders between him and goal. This was essentially a high-risk move. However, there is no evidence that David was brought down; rather, it appeared he actively went down during the challenge."

The on-field referee had insufficient reason to award a free kick, and VAR's intervention and suggestion of a red card exceeded refereeing standards.

Simply put, the red card decision was unfair. The referee's on-pitch decision was reasonable, and VAR should not have intervened.

Why Was Marcus Rashford Ineffective?

Marcus Rashford lacked impact in his comeback match in Spain, posing little threat throughout against Atlético's tough right-side pairing of Marcos Llorente and Giuliano Simeone.

Marcus Rashford had opportunities to show his quality, attempting the most dribbles in the match with five tries, but succeeded only once. What was repeatedly evident throughout the match was that whenever he tried to create danger, he was easily contained by stronger physical challenges from opposing players.

A scene early in the second half illustrates his predicament well. Rashford received the ball in a good position on the left wing, but Simeone quickly dropped back and positioned himself between Rashford and the ball. After gaining the positional advantage, the Argentine caught a moment when his hand brushed Rashford's shoulder, earning a free kick from Swedish referee Nyberg, and Atlético safely cleared the danger.

His lack of intensity and low impact in big games is also why Barcelona wanted to return him to Manchester United on just a one-season loan. Barcelona coach Hansi Flick prefers the more actively running Anthony Gordon and believes he is a better tactical fit.

In the second half, as Carrick pushed for an equalizer, Rashford was one of the first substitutes withdrawn, which came as no surprise.

Could Julián Álvarez Win Over Atlético Fans?

Many Julián Álvarez fans remain frustrated even after his attempt to force a move to Barcelona this summer, and there was some booing when his name was announced before the match.

The early goal improved the stadium atmosphere, and some of Álvarez's excellent ball control helped Atlético maintain possession and continually threaten Manchester United's defense, earning applause.

His long-awaited first goal opportunity for Atlético this season came early in the second half. Barrios provided the perfect cross for a volley, but Álvarez chose to shoot directly and mistimed it, with the ball bouncing off the post.

An even louder round of applause followed that shot. Most fans seem willing to forgive him, though complete reconciliation will take time. But that process has already begun.

AI翻訳。

AFのPCサイトが新登場！パソコンでニュース、コメント、試合詳細、詳細データをご覧いただけます。アクセス：www.allfootballapp.com