Declan Rice, Palmer, Kobbie Mainoo, Rashford and Livramento have all withdrawn from the squad. However it looks like, the withdrawal of key players from England is not a good situation for Thomas Tuchel. The withdrawal of many players has meant that England's priority has slipped back to second place. The Telegraph further highlights that the withdrawal of key players has inevitably raised questions about the relationship between Tuchel and the players. After suffering a heavy defeat to Argentina in the World Cup semi-final, Tuchel faces the difficult task of regaining player trust. Since taking the role, Tuchel has consistently promoted "brotherhood spirit" within the team, but now the public is questioning the authenticity of his words.

Tuchel has always emphasized that he has promoted what is called "brotherhood spirit" within the team during his tenure, and now these comments appear to be hollow. Is this assessment too harsh? Individual player circumstances should be considered on a case-by-case basis, and it is unfair to treat everyone with the same brush.

Over the next three weeks, there are four Nations League matches to play. The England medical team has confirmed the player withdrawals, and the official reasons are physical injuries, which we should accept.

However, a commonly used term in football has emerged – load management. The absences of Rice and Palmer can also be explained by this reasoning. Put simply, it is assessing a player's total appearances and preemptively preventing injury risk from excessive match play.

Palmer took a break during the summer, but Chelsea's explanation is that the intensity of early season matches is very high, and the club does not want him to suffer injuries.

This explanation seems very reasonable. However, Palmer needs to prove himself quickly and reclaim his place in the England squad, yet he is missing all four matches. This decision seems somewhat excessive.

"Load management" is a term we will likely hear more of this season. Players are having to work harder to cope with the physical demands of more intense fixture schedules than ever before.

This issue also touches on the key point of the conflict – tensions are rising between England's coaching staff and the medical departments of individual clubs. We saw this conflict fully emerge last season at Chelsea with the suspension of Enzo Fernández.

Thomas Tuchel must be extremely frustrated. He may even be embarrassed. Is the load management issue something that emerged suddenly after the final Premier League match? Or did the FA and clubs not have sufficient communication about which players needed rest from the start?

It is difficult for outsiders to predict – if Premier League matches were being played this week instead of England fixtures, these players would most likely be on the pitch. That is certain, though it is only speculation. But over the next three weeks, won't they actually be unavailable for just one or two matches?

Palmer and Rice have played full matches for their clubs this week, while Rashford and Mainoo played 77 and 80 minutes respectively in Manchester United matches. Rashford has a minor hip injury that keeps recurring, and Carrick stated that Mainoo's substitution was a tactical decision.

After the heavy defeat to Argentina in the World Cup semi-final, Tuchel faces the difficult task of regaining player trust, as The Telegraph reported on Saturday.

Not all five withdrawing players were World Cup squad members – three of them did not even go to the World Cup. However, the absence of key players inevitably raises questions about the relationship between the manager and players, and the players' desire to play for England.

Palmer did not participate in the World Cup. Mainoo was called up but did not play a single minute. Rashford was in the squad but had limited playing time. Livramento withdrew due to injury before the tournament. Declan Rice played through injury throughout the World Cup. No one disputes that Declan Rice is suffering from excessive physical fatigue and wear.

However, these England matches are not meaningless friendlies or lower-tier competitions. They are Nations League matches, and while not European Championship qualifiers, England will face Spain on Saturday – a world and European champion. Then away matches against the Czech Republic and Croatia, followed by home matches against the same nations. The team needs to perform well, and it is important for Tuchel. These matches are an opportunity to build morale and for Tuchel to prove he is capable of managing this team.

The absence of nearly 20% of the original squad inevitably raises concerns – has England's team reverted to the old era where club interests come first and England's priorities come second? That era was not so long ago.

Whatever one's assessment of Gareth Southgate's management tactics, he worked hard and successfully reversed this trend. Wearing an England shirt should not be a burden, but something the players enjoy, and Southgate tried to make players eager to respond to England's call.

During his playing career, Southgate himself experienced group problems between small clubs and issues that severely hampered England's performance.

While Thomas Tuchel continues to promote "brotherhood spirit" within the team, has he done enough to preserve the spiritual legacy that Southgate left behind?

If these five players' injuries are not serious, and some are absent primarily due to load management considerations, it is difficult to explain their complete withdrawal from the England squad. The compromise would be to rest for this week and return for the final two matches, or at least train with the squad for a period to integrate with the team environment.

Some national teams, such as Germany under Jürgen Klopp, have directly set up two squads to face these four Nations League matches and this extended international break. Intense fixture schedules strain players both mentally and physically.

Thomas Tuchel considered a similar approach but ultimately rejected it. This decision is understandable. However, the reality is clear – many players have chosen to withdraw, and whether this external view is fair or not, England's priority has once again slipped to second place.

AI ဘာသာပြန်ဆိုသည်။

AF ၏ PC ဝဘ်ဆိုက် စတင်ထွက်ရှိပြီ! သင့်ကွန်ပျူတာမှ သတင်းများ၊ မှတ်ချက်များ၊ ပွဲစဉ်အသေးစိတ်နှင့် စာရင်းဇယားများကြည့်ရှုနိုင်သည်။ ဝင်ရောက်ရန်: www.allfootballapp.com