In Premier League Matchday 6, Manchester United drew 1-1 at home against Tottenham, managing only one league victory so far this season. Boos were heard from the home crowd during and after the match, and The Athletic suggests that Manchester United fans are losing confidence in Michael Carrick and the club's transfer recruitment strategy.

According to reports, the two instances of fan reactions heard at Old Trafford during the 1-1 draw with Tottenham perfectly captured their complex feelings toward the current club.

In the 23rd minute, goalkeeper Seny Dieng's long pass went out of play, conceding a throw-in to Tottenham, prompting boos from the stands. While this fan reaction might seem excessive in isolation, it was understandable given the context of the match. Manchester United struggled to control possession and was repeatedly attacked by their opponents. Moreover, Tottenham, visiting Old Trafford, had yet to win in their first five Premier League matches of the season.

Just three minutes into the match, Dieng attempted a short pass to Coby Mainoo but it was cut out by Micky van de Ven, creating a one-on-one chance for Tottenham striker Dominic Solanke, which Dieng superbly saved. Following this incident, facing Tottenham's high pressure, Manchester United's players frequently resorted to long clearances. The team appeared anxious, with underlying concerns about fundamental defensive weakness.

By midway through the first half, Manchester United had completed only 70 passes compared to Tottenham's 170—a striking difference. (Manchester United's performance improved in the second half, finishing with 389 total passes, just one fewer than Tottenham.) By halftime, Tottenham had recorded 9 sequences of 9+ consecutive passes compared to Manchester United's 6. Tottenham's average attacking starting position was 50.8 meters compared to Manchester United's 38.2 meters. The 50.8-meter figure was the highest for an away team at Old Trafford in the first half of this season.

Therefore, following Luke Shaw's back pass, fan boos at Dieng's clearance questioned not just the effectiveness of his pass but his decision-making. A minute earlier, the Belgian goalkeeper had sent a long pass directly to Tottenham center-back Micky van de Ven, with all Manchester United players remaining in their own half, affording the opposition significant space. Dieng's choice to go long this time came after seeing Harry Maguire's midfield pass to Mainoo intercepted again by van de Ven—he was simply seeking a safer option.

Sensing fan frustration, Matheus Cunha, after tackling Brennan Johnson, gestured somewhat angrily at the stands urging the team's support, but his plea was met with a mixed response of applause and boos.

The second notable fan reaction came in the 59th minute. When Carlos Baleba came on as a substitute, thousands of supporters throughout the stadium rose to their feet, welcoming the summer signing's return from injury with tremendous applause and cheers. The scene recalled a hero's return. This outpouring of enthusiasm reflected fans' desperate desire to shift the match's momentum and their hope that Michael Carrick would deliver a new direction for the team.

Baleba symbolized this possibility. The midfielder from Brighton possesses excellent athleticism and an aggressive running style. Having spent five months sidelined with a serious injury, this was his official debut for the club, yet fan expectations for him remained unchanged.

He made an immediate impact. He evaded pressure and sent a curved pass to Bruno Fernandes out wide. He then assisted Bryan Mbeumo's goal, and despite being fouled, chipped the ball to the left wing once more. In the 86th minute, he played a through ball creating an excellent chance for Mbeumo. According to Opta, this was Manchester United's only quality scoring opportunity in the entire match, and fans now look forward to his future performances.

Throughout the match, Baleba completed 12 defensive actions, including 2 tackles, 3 interceptions, and 6 ball recoveries, ranking 7th overall. Though some of his bold passes late in the match didn't reach teammates, his performance justified the enthusiastic welcome and raised a question: why was he Manchester United's third-choice midfielder signing this summer rather than the primary target?

The 22-year-old Cameroonian international suffered an ankle injury during preseason while at Brighton. In fact, Manchester United had the opportunity to sign him as soon as the transfer window opened, but the club first acquired two other midfielders: Youri Tielemans and Andrey Santos. The latter has been on the bench for three Premier League matches and didn't play in this match either.

Youri Tielemans possesses refined ball control skills, but in the Tottenham match his lack of covering and running ability was exposed again. In the first half, right-back Archie Gray carried the ball 20 yards and easily bypassed him, forcing Mbeumo to foul him to stop the play. In the second half, Gray embarked on a 60-yard solo run with the ball, barely challenged, directly evading Tielemans and helping Tottenham create a 4v5 situation outside the penalty area. While Tielemans made a game-high 18 defensive contributions, this match reconfirmed concerns about his stamina. In a preseason interview with Rio Ferdinand, Tielemans discussed his training focus: "After returning from the World Cup, there weren't many running-focused training sessions scheduled."

Bruno Fernandes missed some of Portugal's international matches but played the full 90 in the remaining three fixtures. Since returning to the club, he was frequently seen hitting the ground and regaining his footing, clearly showing accumulated fatigue.

Late in the match, with Sandro Tonali's fitness status uncertain, the team's forward options became thin. Bruno was often pushed up to play striker, with Joshua Zirkzee dropping back to play as attacking midfielder. This scenario prompted reassessment of whether the decision not to significantly strengthen attack this summer was wise.

Tottenham played with 10 men from the 78th minute onward, but the team didn't sit deep defensively, and their attacks intensified late on. Solanke's equalizer was well-deserved, his second duel with Lisandro Martínez in the match, where he consistently maintained physical superiority and capitalized on defensive gaps.

When the final whistle blew, boos rang out as expected, as they had at halftime. While friction between fans and the club over ticketing policy certainly contributed, the primary cause of the booing was the team's poor performance.

Even when former manager Rúben Amorim was in difficult circumstances, fans chanted his name, showing a kind of defiant support. Manchester United fans have consistently backed their manager. And Michael Carrick is the captain of change that the stands desperately seek.

The tense atmosphere at Old Trafford indicates that fans are losing faith in Michael Carrick and the club's recruitment philosophy. Despite his illustrious playing career at Manchester United, Carrick as manager still lacks a dedicated supporters' song.

Fans can only sing his old chant from his playing days and compare him to Scholesy, but in the current circumstances, that feels increasingly outdated.

That song spoke of the magic inherent in Michael Carrick. From January to May last year, it was his leadership that guided the team to Champions League qualification, and this midweek they travel to Madrid to face Atlético. But what fans want to see is the Manchester United that Carrick once anchored—a team brimming with courage and vitality.

AI翻訳。

AFのPCサイトが新登場！パソコンでニュース、コメント、試合詳細、詳細データをご覧いただけます。アクセス：www.allfootballapp.com