| # | Player | Team | Penalty goals |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jimenez | Wolves | 2(2) |
| 2 | Reeco Hackett | Lincoln City | 2(2) |
| 3 | Ryan Manning | Southampton | 1(1) |
| 4 | Gray | Birmingham City | 1(1) |
| 5 | Bowen | West Ham | 1(1) |
| 6 | Lyndon Dykes | Millwall | 1(1) |
| 7 | Zian Flemming | Burnley | 1(1) |
| 8 | Rúben Rodrigues | Bolton Wanderers | 1(1) |
| 9 | Zan Vipotnik | Swansea | 1(1) |
| 10 | Justin Devenny | Stoke | 1(1) |
| 11 | Léo Scienza | Southampton | 1(1) |
| 12 | Isaac Price | West Brom | 1(1) |
| 13 | Tom Cannon | Sheff Utd | 1(1) |
| 14 | Marko Milovanovic | Portsmouth | 1(1) |